WHAT REALLY IS IN THIS PRODUCT!
Special
thanks to the EWG.Org for their laborious efforts in
creating the Skin Deep Site.
To quote Clarins "...wish to "tan" while
safeguarding skin's healthy qualities."
For a product which is to be primarily
applied to the skin there are
23 skin irritants,
a skin sensitizer (Eugenol),
5 ingredients that carry a
"HARMFUL" symbol (Limonene-sensitizer,
Phenoxyethanol-reproductive
defects,
Hydroxyethylcellouse-mutagenic
effects,
Benzyl Benzoate-skin
irritant,
Methylbenzylidene
Camphor-possible
risk of harm to the unborn child),
and a cancer suspect agent/reproductive effects/skin
irritant
(BHT).
This product is not safe and the health
hazards far outweigh the promised look of a
"totally natural-looking, golden
tan." There is not a single reference on their website
that this product is inherently a skin sensitizer.
46% of the ingredients are skin irritants along with 10% of
the ingredients having harmful warning symbols on their
Material Safety Data Sheets.
Ingredients: (from retailer or packaging):
Aqua,
Sorbitan Stearate,
Caprylic/CapricTriglyceride,
Dihydroxyacetone,
C12-15 Alkyl Benzoate, 4-Methylbenzylidene
Camphor,
Glycerin, Diethylhexyl Succinate,
PEG-20 Methyl Glucose Sesquistearate,
Aloe Barbadensis, Stearyl Dimethicone, Butyl
Methoxydibenzoylmethane,
Ethylhexyl Methoxycinnamate,
Cetyl Alcohol,
Dimethicone,
Polyacrylamide,
Sodium Metabisulfite,
Erythrulose, Parfum,
Sesamum
Indicum, C13-14 Isoparaffin,
Hydroxyethylcellulose,
Butylene Glycol,
Betula Alba,
Disodium EDTA,
Tocopheryl Acetate,
Laureth 7, Eupatorium Ayapana,
Magnesium Stearate,
Vanilla Planifolia,
Phenoxyethanol,
Methlyparaben,
Butylparaben,
Ethylparaben,
Propylparaben,
Isobutylparaben,
Sodium Benzoate,
Potassium Sorbate,
BHT,
Benzyl Benzoate,
Benzyl Salicylate,
Coumarin,
Eugenol,
Geraniol,
Hydroxycitronellal,
Isoeugenol,
Limonene,
Linalool,
Hydroxyisohexyl 3-Cyclohexene Carboxaldehyde, Alpha
Isomethyl Ionone
Health
|
Contribution to Score |
Concern |
Description |
Ingredient(s) |
 |
|
2% |
May
contain harmful impurities
or form toxic breakdown
products |
1
ingredient potentially
contaminated with impurities
linked to cancer or other
significant health problems |
TOCOPHERYL ACETATE |
 |
|
3% |
Cancer
- limited evidence of
carcinogenicity |
2
ingredients thought to
possibly cause cancer in
humans, based on limited
data (limited evidence
carcinogen) |
EUGENOL,
COUMARIN |
 |
|
8% |
Potential breast cancer
risks |
5
ingredients posing potential
breast cancer risks |
PROPYLPARABEN,
ETHYLPARABEN,
METHYLPARABEN,
BUTYLPARABEN,
ISOBUTYLPARABEN |
 |
|
2% |
Fragrance - immune,
sensitization, neurotoxicity |
1
ingredient listed as
"fragrance" - unspecified
mixture of chemicals that
have been linked to
potential for immune and
nervous system toxicity |
FRAGRANCE |
 |
|
9% |
Endocrine disruptor |
6
ingredients considered
potential endocrine
disruptor(s), raising
concern for impaired
fertility or development,
and increased risks for
certain cancers |
PROPYLPARABEN,
4-METHYLBENZYLIDENE CAMPHOR,
ETHYLPARABEN,
METHYLPARABEN,
BUTYLPARABEN,
ISOBUTYLPARABEN |
 |
|
16% |
Skin
sensitizer |
10
ingredients with potential
to instigate immune system
response that can include
itching, burning, scaling,
hives, and blistering of
skin (sensitization) |
BHT,
PROPYLPARABEN,
ETHYLPARABEN,
METHYLPARABEN,
EUGENOL,
TOCOPHERYL ACETATE,
LIMONENE,
SODIUM METABISULFITE,
BUTYLPARABEN,
ISOBUTYLPARABEN |
 |
|
5% |
Immunotoxicity hazards |
3
ingredients potentially
harmful to the immune system |
BHT,
EUGENOL,
SODIUM METABISULFITE |
 |
|
6% |
Gastrointestinal or liver
toxicity hazards |
4
ingredients posing potential
gastrointestinal or liver
toxicity hazards |
BHT,
EUGENOL,
COUMARIN,
SODIUM BENZOATE |
 |
|
5% |
Kidney
toxicity hazards |
3
ingredients posing potential
kidney toxicity hazards |
BHT,
SODIUM METABISULFITE,
SODIUM BENZOATE |
 |
|
5% |
Neurotoxicity hazards |
3
ingredients posing
neurotoxicity hazards |
BHT,
EUGENOL,
SODIUM BENZOATE |
 |
|
3% |
Cardiovascular or blood
toxicity hazards |
2
ingredients posing
cardiovascular or blood
toxicity hazards |
COUMARIN,
SODIUM BENZOATE |
 |
|
14% |
Skin
or sense organ toxicity
hazards |
9
ingredients posing skin or
sense organ toxicity hazards |
BHT,
PROPYLPARABEN,
ETHYLPARABEN,
METHYLPARABEN,
EUGENOL,
SODIUM METABISULFITE,
BUTYLPARABEN,
ISOBUTYLPARABEN,
SODIUM BENZOATE |
 |
|
2% |
Penetration enhancer |
1
ingredient that alter(s)
skin structure, allowing
other chemicals to penetrate
deeper into the skin,
increasing the amounts of
other chemicals that reach
the bloodstream (penetration
enhancer) |
DISODIUM EDTA |
 |
|
3% |
Reproductive or
developmental harm - limited
evidence |
2
ingredients thought to
possible present risks to
human reproduction and
development, linked to
potential for reduced
fertility or reduced chance
for a healthy, full-term
pregnancy (limited evidence
reproductive or
developmental toxin) |
PHENOXYETHANOL,
COUMARIN |
 |
|
1% |
Classified as toxic |
2
ingredients considered toxic
in one or more government
assessments |
PHENOXYETHANOL,
SODIUM METABISULFITE |
 |
|
0% |
Potential hazards for
occupational exposures |
1
ingredient posing potential
hazards for occupational
exposures; workplace
exposure limits are in place |
GLYCERIN |
 |
|
0% |
Irritant |
3
ingredients considered an
irritant |
PHENOXYETHANOL,
LIMONENE,
SODIUM METABISULFITE |
 |
|
0% |
Wildlife and environmental
toxicity |
3
ingredients posing potential
risks to wildlife and the
environment through
excretion and disposal of
cosmetics and resulting
contamination of water, air,
or soil |
PHENOXYETHANOL,
LIMONENE,
SODIUM METABISULFITE |
 |
|
Data gaps and not assessed
|
Contribution to Score |
Concern |
Description |
Ingredient(s) |
 |
|
2% |
Not
assessed for safety in
cosmetics by industry panel |
22
ingredients not assessed for
safety by the cosmetic
industry's Cosmetics
Ingredient Review board |
FRAGRANCE,
C13-14 ISOPARAFFIN,
4-METHYLBENZYLIDENE CAMPHOR,
C12-15 ALKYL BENZOATE,
GLYCERIN,
EUPATORIUM AYAPANA (AYAPANA),
DIETHYLHEXYLSUCCINATE,
VANILLA PLANIFOLIA (VANILLA),
BETULA ALBA (BIRCH) EXTRACT,
ERYTHRULOSE,
SESAMUM INDICUM (SESAME),
ALPHA-ISOMETHYL IONONE,
COUMARIN,
PEG-20 METHYL GLUCOSE
SESQUISTEARATE,
HYDROXYISOHEXYL
3-CYCLOHEXENE CARBOXALDEHYDE,
BENZYL SALICYLATE,
LAURETH-7,
AVOBENZONE (PARSOL 1789 |
BUTYL
METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANE),
DIHYDROXYACETONE,
OCTINOXATE (OCTYL
METHOXYCINNAMATE),
GERANIOL,
ALOE BARBADENSIS (ALOE VERA) |
 |
|
0% |
Safety
assessment was based on
related chemical |
3
ingredients with
insufficient toxicity data
to determine safety in
cosmetics - data from a
related chemical has been
used to assess safety |
MAGNESIUM STEARATE,
STEARYL DIMETHICONE,
ISOBUTYLPARABEN |
 |
|
1% |
Risk
assessment method
deficiencies and data gaps |
17
ingredients with maximum
reported "as used"
concentration as basis of
safety assessment by
industry safety panel
(Cosmetic Ingredient Review,
CIR) (implicit known safe
concentration limit in
product) |
BHT,
PHENOXYETHANOL,
PROPYLPARABEN,
DIMETHICONE,
CETYL ALCOHOL,
CAPRYLIC/ CAPRIC
TRIGLYCERIDE,
ETHYLPARABEN,
METHYLPARABEN,
DISODIUM EDTA,
TOCOPHERYL ACETATE,
SODIUM METABISULFITE,
BUTYLENE GLYCOL,
SORBITAN STEARATE,
BUTYLPARABEN,
MAGNESIUM STEARATE,
HYDROXYETHYLCELLULOSE,
POTASSIUM SORBATE |
 |
|
0% |
Pesticide inert of potential
toxicological concern |
1
ingredient used as pesticide
inert, with potential
toxicological concerns: EPA
testing priority |
C13-14 ISOPARAFFIN |
 |
|
Occupational hazards
|
Contribution to Score |
Concern |
Description |
Ingredient(s) |
 |
|
1% |
Dangerous chemical
properties; safety and
handling warnings |
2
ingredients with chemical
properties that may pose
dangers in occupational
settings, or that merit
safety and handling warnings |
LIMONENE,
SODIUM METABISULFITE |
 |
|
|
|
|